Best Garnier Hair Color: Complete Review & Buying Guide

Nowadays, you don’t need to visit a salon to get your hair dyed. Many at-home hair box colors now exist that allow you to get the same professional treatment and results right from the comfort of your home. It might sound sus, but that’s the truth.

These products continue to grow in demand by the day, which just shows how effective they are.

Garnier is one of the few names pop up when looking for the best quality at-home hair box colors.

In this article, we will look at 10 of the best Garnier hair color solutions to keep your hair vibrant and shiny. Not only are these easy to use, but they are also safe and do not damage your locks or leave you with a burnt scalp.

All the products are researched and recommended by our professional hair colorists.

Without wasting any more time, let’s delve in.

Top Garnier Hair Color: Comparison Table

Pick Name	Thumbnail	Product Name	Price
Editor’s Choice		Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing Hair Color Creme, 40 Dark Brown (Dark Chocolate)	Check Price
Best Overall		Garnier Olia Ammonia-Free Brilliant Color Oil-Rich Permanent Hair Color, 3.0 Darkest Brown	Check Price
Best Quality		Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing Hair Color Creme, 100 Extra-Light Natural Blonde	Check Price
4th		Garnier Nutrisse Ultra Color Nourishing Permanent Hair Color Cream, R3 Light Intense Auburn (Red Hair Dye)	Check Price
5th		Garnier Nutrisse Ultra Coverage Hair Color (Spiced Hazelnut)	Check Price
6th		Garnier Olia Ammonia-Free Brilliant Color Oil-Rich Permanent Hair Color, 6.0 Light Brown Hair Dye	Check Price
7th		Garnier Color Sensation Permanent Cream 4.0 Natural Deep Brown	Check Price

Our Top 7 Best Garnier Hair Color Reviews

01. Editor’s Choice: Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing Hair Color Creme, 40 Dark Brown (Dark Chocolate)

Reasons It Stands Out

The Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing Hair Color is one of the best permanent hair colors on the shelf. This hair color has everything you need to achieve a professional finish, from longevity to good smell to easy application.

Since it’s specifically made to nourish and make the hair soft, it is the perfect hair color to have.

It contains avocado, olive oil, and shea butter, which nourishes the hair while coloring it. The presence of fruit oil in its composition also makes it great for conditioning and maintaining the hair color for a long time.

Our Experience with Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing Hair Color

• Easy to apply: The product comes with clear instructions on how to apply it. Even if it’s your first time, you shouldn’t have any problems.
• Ammonia smell: By itself, the cream has a strong ammonia smell, which is common with most hair colors. But you can mix it with the conditioner that comes along with it to make it smell better.
• Softens hair: Besides restoring color, the cream also makes hair soft. This can be a plus if you have thick hair.
• Long-lasting: This is not like any one of those dyes that completely fades off after a few washes. While being permanent doesn’t mean it will last forever, it does have good longevity.

What Didn’t Satisfy Us

The cream takes longer to produce the desired effect. You have to leave it on the hair for a long time before washing it off.

Best for:

Anyone who wants an affordable hair color that works and is easy to use should get this.

Specifications

Pros

• Retains color for a long time
• Long-lasting
• Easy to apply
• Softens hair
• Comes with conditioner

Cons

• May feel itchy when it comes in contact with the skin

02. Best Overall: Garnier Olia Ammonia-Free Brilliant Color Oil-Rich Permanent Hair Color, 3.0 Darkest Brown

Reasons It Stands Out To Us.

The Garnier Plus Hair Color covers gray hair and changes the color completely. It is mild with regard to the smell; it doesn’t have the strong ammonia odor most hair colors have.

There’s also less reaction with the skin. So it’s an excellent choice for people who have very sensitive skin or are allergic to pungent ammonia smell.

Our Experience with the Garnier Olia Brilliant Color

• Ammonia-free: If you’re easily put off by ammonia, then this is the dye for you. As the name suggests, it is ammonia-free.
• Doesn’t burn the scalp: Even when applied deep to the roots and made to came in contact with the scalp, it doesn’t burn the skin.
• Effective against Gray hair: If you’ve tried to remove gray hair with other hair colors and didn’t have success, try out the Garnier Olia. It covers gray hair completely without drying it.
• Not runny: Using a runny hair dye can be quite messy. Luckily, this one is thick and doesn’t run off easily. This makes it very easy to use.

What Didn’t Satisfy Us

The plastic tube containing the developer is very rigid, making it a bit challenging to squeeze the mixture out of the tube.

Best for:

It is perfect for anyone who wants to cover gray hair. It’s also ideal for people with allergies to ammonia or those who have sensitive skin.

Specifications

Pros

• No ammonia smell
• Good pricing
• Last longer
• a tube of conditioner

Cons

• Rigid plastic tube

03. Best quality: Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing Hair Color Creme, 100 Extra-Light Natural Blonde

Reasons It Stands Out To Us

GarnierNutrisseColor Crème is made of fruit oil that enables it to creep into the hair fibers and nourish the hair starting from the tip and going up to the top. It makes the color of the hair more vivid and lasts longer, and effectively covers gray hair if there are any.

If you want a hair color for blonde hair that will greatly improve your hair health, then this is the cream to use.

Our Experience with GarnierNutrisse Hair Color Crème

• Long-lasting: During our first week of trying out the product, first, it was an intense red, then this fades only slightly to a more beautiful red-gold color. It retains this color for a very long time.
• Great for blonde and brown hair: After applying it to dark brown hair, it turns the hair into a beautiful bright strawberry auburn. On red hair, it doesn’t fade like most colors. In other words, the cream delivers a permanent color change even on darker hair.
• Covers gray: It covers gray better than most hair colors and leaves the hair feeling soft after applying the included conditioner.
• Contains fruit oil: The fruit oil in this hair color helps keep the hair looking natural and prevents break-off.

What didn’t Satisfy Us

The color came out like a dark mud brown, not exactly copper-like as we had expected.

Best for:

It is perfect for blonde hair.

Specifications

Pros

• Smells good
• Natural look
• Long-lasting
• Easy to apply

Cons

• Dark mud brown color

04. Garnier Nutrisse Ultra Color Nourishing Permanent Hair Color Cream, R3 Light Intense Auburn (Red Hair Dye)

Reasons It Stands Out To Us

The GanierNutrisse Ultra is one of the best

Nourishing permanent hair color creams in the market. It doesn’t only color but also nourishes and smells great.

Again, the key ingredient is triple fruit oil, a blend of shea oils, avocado, and olive. The formula is non-drip and produces a permanent color change.

Our Experience with Garnier Nutrisse Ultra Color Nourishing Permanent Hair Color Cream

• Softens hair: The hair feels noticeably soft after applying the cream.
• Long-lasting: After applying this product and washing the hair multiple times, the color still looks as good as new; no fading. Even when it eventually fades, it fades to a beautiful brown color.
• Large quantity: Just one pack is enough to get the job done, even on long hair.
• Complete gray coverage: The cream works really well in covering grayness. It provides 100 percent coverage, so you have nothing to worry about.

What didn’t satisfy us?

It didn’t smell very nice.

Best for:

Overall highly recommend it for anyone, light or dark hair, who wants RED hair. Not for sensitive, itchy or damaged skin scalp.

Specifications

Pros

• Easy to use
• Relatively affordable
• Large quantity in every pack
• Covers gray hair
• It leaves the hair feeling soft

Cons

• The scent is not so nice

05. Best-selling: Garnier Nutrisse Ultra Coverage Hair Color (Spiced Hazelnut)

Reasons It Stands Out To Us

Nutrisse Ultra Coverage is simple to use, has a pleasant scent, and does not drip. It’s made using cover plus technology that allows it to cover grey hair perfectly. It comes with a quality conditioner which helps to soften the hair and leave it in good condition.

Our Experience with the Garnier Nutrisse Ultra Coverage

• Non-drip: The formula is non-drip, so it spreads evenly without creating a mess. It leaves the hair looking nice and polished.
• Great for less oily hair: We noticed that this hair color gives the best results when applied on less oily hair and hair that hasn’t been washed recently.
• Doesn’t cause sinus migraines: The cream doesn’t cause sinus migraines like some of its counterparts.
• Permanent color change: The cream is formulated with color boost technology, which helps deliver a permanent color change even to dark hair without fading.

What didn’t satisfy us?

Though it’s good and affordable, the color doesn’t last long.

Best for:

Those with stubborn gray hair and want to cover them fully

Specifications

Pros

• Easy to apply
• No awful smell (mild ammonia scent)
• Perfect gray hair cover
• Easy to rinse
• Cost-effective

Cons

• Doesn’t take long to fade

06. Garnier Olia Ammonia-Free Brilliant Color Oil-Rich Permanent Hair Color, 6.0 Light Brown Hair Dye

Reasons It Stands Out For Us

Garnier Olia Hair Color is one of the few hair colors that have no ammonia. It produces vivid, dazzling color results.

The formula enhances hair color significantly by reversing the roughness and dullness caused by the oils. It is the go-to formula when you want to achieve a nice color shine.

The kit comes with a user manual that is easy to read and understand and a pair of gloves; this makes it easy for anyone to apply. More importantly, the smell is nice.

Our Experience With Garnier Olia Ammonia-Free Permanent Hair Color

• Covers Gray hair: the formula fully covers gray hair without drying out the hair.
• No strong ammonia smell: Most chemical hair colors have an awful ammonia odor, but that is not the case with this product. It doesn’t have a strong ammonia smell.
• Doesn’t burn: Even when the color is left for long without washing, it doesn’t burn the scalp. This is a big improvement on the part of Garnier, as most hair colors often burn the skin when left for too long.
• Leaves hair feeling soft and silky: The cream contains oils that nourish the hair leaving it soft and silky.

What didn’t satisfy us?

The gloves provided are really big and may not fit.

Best for:

Anyone who wants to change their hair color to looking to natural light brown

Specifications

Pros

• Available in several color options
• Thick texture (not runny)
• No sharp chemical smell
• Easy to apply
• Comes with a conditioner and gloves

Cons

• Big gloves

07. Garnier Color Sensation Permanent Cream 4.0 Natural Deep Brown

Reasons It Stands Out For Us

The Garnier Sensation Hair Color Cream is the first permanent hair color by the brand that is enriched with mother-of-pearls and flower extract. It produces a natural deep brown color that shimmers with mirror brilliance and provides complete coverage.

The thick cream texture spreads on the hair evenly and doesn’t drip.

Our Experience with the Garnier Color Sensation Permanent Cream

• Long-lasting effect: The formula produces a permanent color that lasts 6-8 weeks.
• Softens the hair: The hair is left feeling soft and beautiful to touch.
• Pleasant floral scent: The cream has a floral fragrance which is something to be excited about, as it makes the whole application process more enjoyable—no more awful ammonia smell.
• Works on dark hair: The cream still achieves the same effect on dark hair. For instance, on natural black hair, it will still change the color to a lovely deep brown

What didn’t satisfy us?

Some people might see the color as too dark.

Best for:

Anyone who wants to color their hair deep brown

Specifications

Pros

• Easy to use
• Does not drip
• Nice floral fragrance
• Leaves hair feeling soft
• Leaves behind a glossy finish

Cons

• Might be too dark for some people

Garnier Hair Color: Buying Guide

Here are the key things to consider when buying Garnier’s hair color.

Type

The Garnier hair color has a wide range of shades; this range from natural-looking shades to bold colors and inspired pastels. To determine which type suits you best, first, you must consider what you want to do with your hair. Do you want to change color drastically or just add a warm tone? Do you want to cover the gray?

Having the answers to these questions will determine which hair color you need.

Safety

Garnier hair color is made of ingredients that are safe for external body use. However, before deciding on the exact one you want to buy, you should read all the labeling and instructions and determine the exact ingredients used for that specific dye. If your body is allergic to any component, then you may want to select another product just to be on the safe side.

Price Range

The prices of Garnier hair colors vary depending on the composition, color, and type of items in the package. So depending on the amount of money you wish to spend, you can select the one that will best suit your needs.

Durability

This simply means either permanent or temporally color change. When selecting your Garnier hair color, you need to have decided how long you need to have the dye on. If you just want the dye for a specific occasion then reverts to your current color, then you should go for a temporary or semi-permanent Garnier hair color. On the other hand, if you want a dye that will last longer without fading, then you should go for the one with permanent colors.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Question: Is Garnier hair color ammonia free?

Answer: Not all Garnierhair colors are ammonia-free. Some formulas contain ammonia, while there are other formulas like GarnierOlia that are ammonia-free.

Question: Is Garnier’s hair color safe during pregnancy?

Answer: Yes. The ingredients used do not affect you or your unborn baby. The only precaution is that the difference in your hormones may alter the desired color effect.

Question: Is Garnier hair color safe?

Answer: Yes. It’s 100% safe. However, all chemical dyes are made of ingredients that may be allergic. Therefore you must carry out a skin allergy test before using any of Garnier’s hair colors for the first time.

Question: Which Garnier hair color is semi-permanent?

Answer: All Garnier hair color is permanent, mostly the color lasts more than four weeks depending on how fast your hair grows.

Conclusion

At-home hair color solutions have come a long way, and Garnier has been part of that success story.

Whether you wish to give your hair a fresh look or get a quick fix to conceal roots or gray hairs, you don’t need to look too far. You can achieve that and more using one of the best Garnier hair colors listed above.

These colors produce the same professional results as those you get at a salon, but without the extra expenses and time.

Let us know if you have any more questions or suggestions about these hair colors. Until then, happy coloring!